Lycoming County Unsolved Homicide Cases_2021

Top, from left: Rodney Hager (Crimewatch), Ayliem Coleman (Gunmemorial.org), Semaj Mozee (Facebook), Riley McDowell (File photo), Joline Witt (Crimewatch). Bottom, from left: William Blackwell (Williamsport Police), Edward Baluta (Crimewatch), Tamara Berkheiser and Gail Matthews (Lycoming County District Attorney), Amir Nobels (Gunmemorial.org).

Williamsport, Pa. – Decades pass and some homicide victims and their families still wait for justice in Lycoming County.

Renowned cold case detective Kenneth Mains recently reviewed a list of unsolved homicides compiled by NorthcentralPA.com

"Most of the time it’s not what you know but it’s what you can prove...beyond a reasonable doubt," Mains said about solving cold cases.

Mains has written several books on the topic and starred in shows on the History Channel, the Discovery Science Channel, and A&E. He no longer lives in Pennsylvania but his career as a detective began here in Lycoming County.

"I worked for District Attorney Eric Linhardt for seven years and reviewed every Lycoming County unsolved case. Some cases I agreed with the original investigators and some I did not," Mains said. "Although I am haunted at times by these cases, I can sleep knowing I did the absolute best I could with the resources that were afforded to me."

Williamsport homicides 

Williamsport Police - homicides 2009-2019

Homicide offenses reported and cleared by the Williamsport Police Department for years 2009-2019. Source: FBI Uniform Crime Reporting

FBI Uniform Crime Reporting data show that almost all of Lycoming County's unsolved homicides occurred in and around its population center: Williamsport.

"There isn't always a video. There's isn't always a star witness. There isn't always somebody who wants to go against their entire neighborhood and the entire history of their family and upbringing and risk their life to take the witness stand, which is exactly what some of them are feeling when they do that," Williamsport Chief of Police Damon Hagan said about the county's unsolved cases.

Hagan said it would be unfair to criticize police administrators or politicians for the county's unsolved cases when arrests and convictions depend on a witness risking their life to testify – an unrealistic expectation.

"We believe that is an unfair criticism of the police in general," Hagan said.

Between 2009 and 2019, Williamsport Police cleared 76% of homicide offenses, according to FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) data. In other words, 26 out of 34 Williamsport homicides were cleared during the most recent reporting decade. 

Mains1.jpg

Cold case detective Kenneth L. Mains. 

Williamsport's clearance rate is significantly better than the state's average of 65% for the same time period, according to Project: Cold Case.

The FBI cautions against comparing one law enforcement agency's clearance rate with another's. Numerous sociological factors contribute to crime activity and reporting: population density, employment rates, administrative policies, and community attitudes.

For example, neighboring Clinton County reports no unsolved homicide cases with at-large suspects. Lock Haven, Clinton County's seat, is one-third the size of Williamsport.

"I don’t think it would be fair to compare Lycoming County to Clinton County as it relates to unsolved cases," Mains said.

Is there such a thing as an "average" or expected number of cold cases?

"There is no average amount in my opinion. Solving a case has so many variables," Mains said.

Solvability matrix

Some cold case investigators use a solvability matrix to score the presence of factors like fingerprint evidence, eyewitnesses, or recovered weapons.

Mains said other variables include the investigating officer's knowledge and passion and having enough probable cause for a judge to grant an arrest warrant.

"Then you need some luck because if all these things happen then the district attorneys still have to believe they can win at trial and sign off on it. It’s a long process as it should be when people’s lives are at stake," Mains said.

A 'crisis situation'

When murders go unsolved, it's a public safety risk because violent offenders are likely to repeat, former Pennsylvania State Trooper Tom McAndrew said in the U.S. Department of Justice article The Crisis of Cold Cases. Mounting unsolved caseloads drain resources and result in higher costs for agencies with limited budgets.

"Cold cases constitute a crisis situation, for all unsolved homicides potentially have offenders who have never been apprehended," McAndrew said.

The Lycoming County District Attorney's Office renewed focus last year on the 1994 cold case of Gail Matthews, 23, and her daughter Tamara Berkheiser, 5. The DA's office has physical evidence – bloodstained sheets, pillows, and the clothing of the decedents – that can be re-tested for DNA.

"There’s an obligation we have to the family to not stop till we reach a dead end, which we haven't," First Assistant District Attorney Martin Wade said of the Matthews/Berkheiser case. "This case isn’t an accident. Someone brutally murdered these people."

Mains.jpg

Cold case detective Kenneth L. Mains.

What types of cold cases tend to be reopened?

Cold cases are most likely to be reopened under the following circumstances in order of importance, according to research by the RAND Center on Quality Policing:

  1. New witness information
  2. Availability of DNA to submit to databases
  3. New information from citizens or informants
  4. IAFIS-quality fingerprint evidence
  5. Availability of outstanding leads
  6. Murder weapon recovered
  7. Suspect identified
  8. Recovery of projectiles or casings to submit to databases
  9. Potential of obtaining additional witness information
  10. Case fits serial pattern
  11. Victim identified
  12. Evidence properly handled and stored
  13. Case file complete and retrievable
  14. Aggravating circumstances (innocence of victim, hate crime, heinousness of crime)
  15. Original investigator case notes available
  16. Queries from family members
  17. Original investigator available for interview
  18. Statute of limitations about to expire
  19. Media attention paid to case

Sometimes a detective's contribution to a cold case isn't solving it but rather helping to move the investigation forward. 

"Sometimes it’s just being a fresh set of eyes to see something others have missed...that gives the detective a new lead," Mains said. "Ask any detective worth a shit and they will tell you all they want in an unsolved case is to have another lead to follow up on."

NorthcentralPA.com News Director/Reporter Carrie Pauling contributed to this report.

Related reading: Cold case evidence to be re-tested for DNA in mother-daughter homicides

This article was updated to add Randy Speck to the list of unsolved cases. 


Support our journalism

Our content is free, but our journalists work hard. 100% of your contribution to NorthcentralPa.com goes directly toward helping us cover the important news and events in our region. Thank you for saying that local news matters!